We’ve
already dealt with free will and determinism; however,
you may still wonder what’s the origin of your mind. According to tabula rasa theory your mental content
comes only from your experience. The
meaning of tabula rasa originates from Latin “blank slate” or “white paper”; it
means that you’re born with an empty mind which is to be filled with your life
experiences which, according to tabula rasa theory, are the unique source of
mental content. One of the most famous philosophers who held belief in tabula
rasa is probably English philosopher John
Locke who claimed that “all
ideas come from sensation or reflection”. It sounds reasonable, doesn’t it?
Personally,
I don’t believe in tabula rasa theory. There are numerous literary works which
aim to prove that we are not born
with tabula rasa. Some of them (such as "Lord of the Flies" by W. Golding) seem
to convince the reader of an innate evil, others (such as a classic of children’s
literature "Pollyanna" by E. H. Porter) claim that all people are born good. It
shows how different philosophical theories may be when it comes to mind – tabula rasa, innate evil, or
innate goodness. Are you really born with tabula rasa then?
John Locke (1632-1704) |
There are
various scientific experiments which show that a foetus is able to hear what
happens outside the womb. He can hear his mother’s voice and is even able to distinguish
it from other voices; some claim that music influences foetus’s IQ and
personality. Of course there is still no consensus about how much foetus can hear (and to what
extent it influences his future life) but most scientists agree that foetus does hear. And hearing is undeniably an
experience which is, according to Locke, a source of knowledge. Is tabula rasa theory
false? What do you think about it?
A priori knowledge exists. Some call it instinct.
ReplyDeleteI don't think that instinct is or requires knowledge
DeleteNature vs Nurture
ReplyDeleteI'm going with the theory that John Locke has define Tabula rasa the human development of the mind at birth. Born with Goodwill is a given depending on the Nurturing part of ones life.
Born with good will a given? I think one is born with the ability to react to stimuli and one does not have to be of good will to do so. Stimuli can be sounds, touch, light, temparature etc. Experiencing stimuli and reacting to them is part of the start of life outside the womb. We learn from our reactions which ones result in good stuff, like a cuddle or an other response and we take it from there. Bein a tabula rasa at brith does not mean we are stupid, just as yet without knowledge.
Deletegenes don't control behavior, the signal from the quantum field does.
DeleteEpi-as in on top of genes, Epigenetic influences not Newtonian celectial machine mechanics.
Born with "experience" is inherently different than natural instinct. That would be the fallacy in your argument.
ReplyDelete